How To Make Cake Pops With The Babycakes Cake Pop Maker – Tips, Tricks & Resources

When I make cakepops, more often than not I make them using the Babycakes Cake Pop Maker.

I received this as a gift, and honestly my first thought was “gimmick”.   Well it turns out, it’s a great little machine and extremely useful.   I LOVE the taste of cake pops made this way, compared to the cake and frosting method, and you can add a filling if you like.

Amazon sells it for less than $25, with free shipping if you have Amazon Prime (I love Amazon Prime almost as much as cake – saves me so much running to stores with a toddler in tow!).   Kohls often has it on sale and if you can catch it with a sale and a coupon, you can usually get a great price.

The question I get the most about the Babycakes Cake Pop Maker is how I get my cake pops roundwith many people telling me that theirs come out flat or and odd shape.   My immediate question is if they used a regular cake mix or a recipe from Babycakes.   It’s almost always the regular mix.

Given that a regular mix still requires adding ingredients, measuring and mixing, it only takes a few more quick steps to make them from scratch using one of the Babycakes recipes.  Making a recipe from scratch with the cake pop maker is still quicker than the original method of baking a cake, and then chopping it up and mixing it with frosting and shaping the balls by hand.

Babycakes has their instruction manual, with recipes, available on their website.  I absolutely LOVE the vanilla recipe that is in the manual, and it’s my go to recipe for cake pops, it reminds me of pound cake.  I’ve found each one that I’ve tried to be delicious and they work great with the machine.   I am very excited that they have a brand new cookbook of cake pop recipes with 175 cake pop recipes.   I can not wait to try them.

My take is that if you are going to use the machine, use one of their recipes.  They’ve been developed for and tested in the Babycakes machine.   The included instruction manual includes some great recipes and they also offer recipes on their website.  I’m not saying cake mixes won’t work, I just think that it makes sense that you will get the best results following a recipe that was made specifically for this purpose.    The Babycakes recipes seem to produce a much thicker batter, which certainly makes it easier to fill the wells of the machine.    I put my batter into a Ziploc freezer bag and “pipe” it into the wells.   I tried this with a cake mix and it was not fun, the cake mix was just too runny.   I also saw a suggestion in the Babycakes Tips section where a reader said she used a Pancake Pen for her batter – which sounds like an excellent idea that I might have to try.

If you want to stick to a mix, Babycakes does sell mixes specifically made for the Cake Pop Maker.  I believe that these are available at Kohl’s in addition to the Babycakes online shop.  If you want to use a store bought mix, I recommend cutting back on the amount of liquid in the recipe.  This is something that is likely going to be different with each brand and flavor, meaning there is no blanket “cut back x amount”.    I would also recommend adding a bit more baking powder to the mix, even if just half a teaspoon.   The Babycakes Tips page really has some great advice from readers, and this thread has some great info on using a regular cake mix in your cake pop machine.

Another fun thing about making your cake pops with the Babycakes machine is that you can easily add/inject a filling into the cake pops!  We’ve only used frosting (because we love frosting) but I’m sure you could put lots of other yummy fillings in.

Here is a great video from Bed, Bath & Beyond on using the Babycakes Cake Pop Maker.

Also, check out this fantastic video from Ahh’s Cakes where she uses the Babycakes Cake Pop Maker and goes through every step – it’s about ten minutes long and very helpful.  She appears to be using one of the Pancake Pens to dispense her batter.   I also found a demo video on AllRecipes.   It’s a bit fast (and dark) but might be helpful.

The Babycakes Cakepop Maker might take a bit of practice (though I have to say my very first batch turned out quite nicely), but I really think it’s worth figuring it out, especially if you need to make large batches of cake pops.   It also makes some delicious donut holes.  There are other cake pop makers and pans, such as the Bake Pop Pan.   I haven’t tried it, so can’t speak for how it works.

Here are some links to other sites talking about the Babycakes Cake Pop Maker…

Babycakes Cake Pop Maker Review at The Party Animal

Babycakes Cake Pops on the Wilton Forums

 Sweet Potato Pancake Balls & Babycakes Cake Pop Maker at Savoring The Thyme

I Will Never Buy A Cake Again – Babycakes Cakepop Maker at Moscato Mom

Make sure to check out this post for tips, advice, idea and resources for dipping and decorating your cake pops and thoughts on some common cake pop challenges such as getting the chocolate smooth, preventing the chocolate from cracking and getting the cake pops to stay on their sticks.

Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterGoogle+Pin on Pinterestshare on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon

Comments

  1. Lynsey @MoscatoMom says

    Hey there! What a fantastic post!! I am totally in love with my Babycakes Maker and have made all KINDS of “pops” in mine – from Pancake Pops to CornDog Pops – I think they are a MUST for all moms as you can make TONS of things in them!

    As for the “getting the pops round” – I have found that either the Babycakes Recipes – which are all fantastic – OR Pillsbury box cake mix works well. When I make “decorated” pops I use the Funfetti cake mix and just use a bit less water than it calls for, and they always turn out perfect :)

  2. Averie @ Love Veggies and Yoga says

    I have a babycakes maker, too! A couple of them :) I haven’t played around with it as much as I thought I would (between Xmas baking season and Valentine’s Day and 2 bdays in our house…I’ve had a full calling card of other desserts…ha!)

    I totally agree with your logic that if you’re going to buy it, use their recipes b/c they work specifically for the machine. The cake mix method works, but not as good as their recipes.

    Love that you’re injecting them with frosting!

  3. Jody says

    Your website is such a wonderful inspiration. I’m just starting and no where near the quality of your info. So thanks, for the inspiration.
    With that said, I love my Baby Cakes pop maker. I got it on sale at Kohls for $19.99 with a 30 % coupon! Woo hoo! You have to try Brownies ( I used the Duncan Hines box mix with miniature peanut butter cups) but they have others or you could make your own of course. But they are delicious even without icing. Super quick treat.

  4. Christy says

    I just wanted to leave a quick but great recipe for cake batter mix out the box:
    Ingredients:
    • 1 box cake mix (any flavor u desire)
    • eggs according to the cake mix box
    • milk substituted for the water
    • 1 box instant pudding suitable to flavor of cake mix
    •••• Mix all ingredients. Batter comes out thick & cake balls are perfect : )

  5. Kim says

    If you use regular cake mix, and they come out lopsided, just put a little more batter in the well, and place the flat/non-round side into it and bake again for the 3 minutes. It will make it a perfect ball.

  6. Lauren A. says

    Hey there! I love making cake pops, and I use a regular cake mix every time. The thing that I do to make sure the pops come out round every time is I fill the wells in the top half of the machine (this requires laying it with that side down) until they are heaping. Then I close the bottom half onto the top until it locks down and then I can easily rotate the machine back to bottom side down. I usually rotate side to side to give even coating of batter there as well. Since I started doing that, I have never had a problem with the pops not coming out round! I love your pops and I think they are gorgeous!

  7. Jayma says

    Heilo! Im all new to making baking treats and my oven is actually broke. Im so glad I came across your website on my search for a cake pop machine! I’m planning to make cake pops for dessert for my baby’s one year bday party. Your blog made me decide to go ahead n order the babycakes cake pop maker and im loving all the tips and tricks you are sharing! I can’t wait to try it out! your cake pops are beautiful!

  8. MishyMunch says

    Hi, I was just wondering if anyone has tried the crumble method to make cake pops instead of the babycakes maker. Which one tastes better?

    I have been using the babycake make (with boxed mix) and I find them not as moist and they get a little overpowered by my candy melts

  9. Jennifer B says

    I use Wilton’s cream cheese filling recipe (on their website) to fill my cake pops. I’ve used it with red velvet, devil’s food and vanilla with great results!

  10. janine says

    hi there i am starting to do pop cake and i am just wonering can u use normul cake. I am looking at getting one of these cake pop makers if anyone can help thanks in advance

  11. Tiffani says

    I got mine back in March for my bday and just now pulled it out, the batch was very easy it was the icing part that was hard. But me and my kids had a great time. It was easy to clean as well. :)

  12. Mandy says

    Was just wondering if I could make profiteroles in one. Got a Croquembouche to make and it would make it a lot easier – do you think it would work? Btw I don’t have a cake pop maker yet, I make them in the old-fashioned way with my hands. I’m just weighing up the pros and cons of getting one ………. comments would be appreciated, thanks!

    • Christi says

      Mandy, I can’t say for sure as I have never tried, but I have heard of people having success. I really don’t see why it wouldn’t work. Good luck!

  13. Maria Castano says

    Hello everyone!!! I need helpp !!!!! The machine works great but I’m having trouble having the lollipop sticks, stick to the balls. Obviosly, I dip the sticks into the candy melts, but when I dip the balls they tend to gel loose!!!!
    What can I do??????
    Any advice…..?????
    Thanks

  14. fms says

    Firstly, I love my cake pop machine, quick and works like a charm. Get used to working fast and piping your batter is a plus. To get the pops to stay on stick and to really hold icing quickly, I make my cake balls ahead, freeze them for a while. Dip the sticks into the frosting first and then instert them into the frozen cake pop. I then let them set standing upright for at least 5 or 10 mins, then I dip frost them. Also, be careful with the cooking of your pops, sometimes the culprit is that the cake is too light to hold and or there is an air pocket in the center. If these occur it is more likely that your pop wont stay on the stick no matter what icing you use to glue it on. I also tend to slightly undercook my pops so that the center is still moist(always a plus) and dense enough to withstand the weight and grip the stick. Its never an exact science but with practice, it comes and it is always fun.

  15. Hannah says

    I just bought a Babycakes Cake Pop Maker yesterday after my kids kept begging for one. I was searching for how to do it correctly and found this blog post. Thank you!

  16. Amber says

    I thinking of purchasing a Babycakes Cake Pop maker in the next day or so. I’ve heard many great things about the original CP-12 model, but there is also one that allows you flip the maker with a twist (see link): http://thebabycakesshop.com/cp-34r . Do any of you have this model, think it is worth the extra $10-15, or is the original the way to go?

    I’d love to buy this to avoid spending $60+ to have a bakery make cake pops for a baby shower I’m helping host next week.

  17. adckam says

    I made the cake balls, and they turned out great, but I had a problem with the frosting. I melted the Wilton Candy Melts, but when I dipped the balls into the melted chips the frosting was too thick, and the frosting didn’t go on with a nice film over the cake ball, it was too thick. Any suggestions?

  18. Amaria says

    Hi – has anyone tried Christy’s recipe (posted on February 20, 2012 at 9:20 pm)? When the cake box recipe calls for oil, should I use oil in the recipe, or leave it out?

    Thanks for the help!!

  19. kim ayars says

    hi i have bought the donut one as a present but i want a cake pop one..
    would baked cheesecake work as cake pops preferabley gluten free. Could you please let me know if anyone has made these in this. thank you
    k

  20. Karen says

    Hi There…I just bought my BAbycakes Cake Pop and am wondering if anyone has a recipe to make cheesecake pops in it???
    Karen:)

  21. Natalie says

    Read all your posts and then tackled my new cake pop maker. I’d bought a pre-packaged (Duncan HInes) cupcake mix to give it a go and the results were great! I made it exactly as the box said to, without substituting anything. I put too much in the maker to start with, and I was a bit slow with a spoon so I’ll be trying the piping bag idea next time, but it was really easy. Kids loved them….in fact I think I have about a dozen left out of the four dozen the mix made…yesterday! Can’t wait to buy a book for lots more ideas and recipes.

  22. Arielle says

    Thank you so much for this post! I’ve been wanting to try the cake pop maker by Babycakes. I’ve tried making them by scratch with frosting and cake but they didn’t turn out that well and were not easy to make. I’m going out and buying a Babycakes maker today. I can’t wait to use the tips on this post to make cake pops!!!

  23. Barbra says

    Thank you sooo much for this. I purchased a cake pop maker last week and my daughter and I played with it that night, it was a nightmare. No where on the box did it say anything about not using cake mixes, so I did, and it was bad. The edges burned, and the middle wasn’t cooked. The instruction book said it was best to use pound cake of muffin mixes…..but there were also recipes in there too……so when I was done and everything was terrible, it went into the closet. Now, after reading your information, I will pull it out again tonight when I get home and try again!!!!! Thank you!!

  24. LO says

    Christie! Did you buy and try the Babycakes Flip model? Is it worth the extra money?

    ———————

    Amber says:
    SEPTEMBER 13, 2012 AT 8:48 PM
    I thinking of purchasing a Babycakes Cake Pop maker in the next day or so. I’ve heard many great things about the original CP-12 model, but there is also one that allows you flip the maker with a twist (see link): http://thebabycakesshop.com/cp-34r . Do any of you have this model, think it is worth the extra $10-15, or is the original the way to go?

    I’d love to buy this to avoid spending $60+ to have a bakery make cake pops for a baby shower I’m helping host next week.

    Christi says:
    SEPTEMBER 14, 2012 AT 6:13 AM
    Amber, I just received the new flip over style. I will be trying it out this weekend and sharing my review next week.

  25. melisss says

    I was wondering… I used boxed Devil’s food cake mix. It was awesome and thick and made perfect rounds balls. But I do agree that the old way of adding frosting and molding the balls was more moist. So I have 2 questions. .. one; what if I add frosting to the uncooked mix and then bake in my cakepop machine. Would that cook and make balls more moist? And what about regular boxed cake mixes? I used a white cake mix and added maraschino cherry chucks. But the batter was to thin and didnt form nice big balls. Any advice on thicken box cake mixes?

    • Christi says

      Melisss, I have pretty much stuck with the recipes from Babycakes. I believe somewhere on their site or cookbook (their Cakepop cookbook is incredible) they talk about modifying mixes a bit. I’m not sure about adding frosting in when baking. You could inject some into the baked cake ball prior to covering in chocolate. A frosting filled cake pop! :)

  26. Marie says

    Hi Christie,
    Great post! Quick question, when you use the cake mix recipe posted above (with pudding mix), do you still also add the oil as per the box instructions, or is the only liquid the milk?
    Thank you! I bought a smaller version cake pop machine (Nostalgia electrics) and can’t wait to try it!
    Best,
    Marie

    • Christi says

      Hi Marie, thanks so much – glad it’s helpful. I pretty much always make my cake pops using the recipes from Babycakes. The vanilla one in their owner manual (link in the post) is so delish and so easy (truly only a minute or two more time than a box mix), and I like how predictable the results are. If I use the Babycakes Cake Pop Mix, I just follow the directions as written on the box. :) Hope that helps.

  27. Jennifer says

    I was wondering if anyone has made a savoy cake pop with the maker? I think it would be great to make a breakfast one with sausage, ham or bacon or an appetizer version. I am gonna experiment…

  28. Mayan Rowling says

    Hiya,
    I was wondering if any of you have a recipe for white choc mud cake that is suitable for the cake ball maker? If so can you please share it?
    Thanks
    Mayan

  29. janine says

    Hi there! I live in SA but we don’t have the cake pops machine, only the pans. I used regular cake mix, but I agree it doesn’t work that well. I would like to know how do you ice your cake pops. They are so soft and moist, it totally breaks when I tried to ice mine.

  30. Hope says

    I bought mine less than a month ago and have made close to 150 pops so far. I love this little machine!!! It has made my life SO much easier!

  31. Leeann says

    Just a lil info i used a regular cake mix but used milk in place of the water left out the oil and added an egg to what the mix called for and it worked perfectly for my first time using my cakepop maker…

  32. Leanne says

    I used a 3 egg Duncan Hines Moist Deluxe box mix and divided approximately into THIRDS. I used my kitchen scale for accuracy and then only used 1/2 of the oil and 1/2 of the milk…

    1/3 cake mix
    65ml milk
    20 ml oil
    1 egg

    Turned out great. Frosted devils chocolate balls with premium Duncan Hines Creamy Homestyle mixed with white chocolate chips and nuked in 15sec intervals so as to only warm and NOT boil.
    Fantastic 1st effort!!

Trackbacks

  1. [...] I say “about” two minutes, because the temperature was all over on this.  I’ve professed my love for the Babycakes line of products (cake pop maker, donut maker, cupcake maker and pie maker), and this machine (which is not made by [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>