Without a doubt, my daughter’s favorite dessert of all time is the deep dish style pizza cookies from Oregano’s. They are also referred to as Pizookie by BJ’s Restaurant and I’ve even heard them called Cookies A La Mode. Who cares what you call them, as long as you can get your hands on them. A warm, not completely baked cookie base that is topped with cool creamy ice cream. It may just be the ultimate dessert.
For quite some time I’ve made these at home using store bought cookie dough, following the directions from Our Best Bites. It works out great. But I do not always have cookie dough on hand and it seems to be getting harder and harder to find cookie dough that is completely nut free, so I figured it was time to make these from scratch. You can really use any cookie recipe – at the holidays we made them using my Levain Bakery Copycat Double Chocolate Chip Cookie recipe.
While any cookie recipe will probably work, I wanted to have a recipe that makes one single serving (granted, it’s generous enough that you can share if you are so inclined). And I wanted to be able to make them in the microwave. Here’s what we have…
Yum. Are you ready?
This is pretty straight forward. You will need…
SINGLE SERVING DEEP DISH COOKIE A LA MODE
1.5 to 2 TBSP Melted Butter
1 TBSP Sugar
1 TBSP Brown Sugar
1/8 TSP Vanilla
1/4 Cup Flour (go with a scant 1/4 cup vs a generous 1/4 cup)
Sprinkle Of Salt If Desired
1/8 TSP Baking Powder
Chocolate Chips To Taste
Melt your butter in a microwave safe bowl. You can in make and cook these in one container, but I made mine in a measuring cup and cooked in a ramekin. I think mugs are a popular option for these microwavable desserts. After melting the butter, add in both sugars and vanilla and stir well.
Next add in your flour, salt and baking powder.
Stir to combine. Add in your chocolate chips – you can use as many or as few as you would like. Also feel free to add nuts or other mix ins.
Now it’s time to pop it into the microwave and cook. This is where there is a fair amount of variation. You could cook for as little as 40 seconds or as much as one minute and 20 seconds. This will depend on your microwave and what you want your cookie to be like. There are no eggs in this, so you are probably safe to go on the more undercooked side (my fave!).
These are best if they are immediately topped with ice cream and devoured. Yummy.
Hard to resist.
Are brownies more your style? Make sure to try the Brownie A La Anytime – just a minute in the microwave and you have warm brownie goodness ready to enjoy.
WOW! Thanks for this recipe! You totally read my mind…I wanted to do something similar for my hubs’ birthday tomorrow but I didn’t have it in me to recipe test. So I made deep dish cookies (way too many of them). Love this recipe!
Sounds great! And I like mine undercooked too, yummy
This looks awesome, Christ! You’re on a roll with these micro desserts
You and Jenny/picky both have nearly the same posts/recipes that went live within an hour or so of each other. I need cookies, now!
Averie, haha – get on it girl!!! Clearly Jenny and I were of the same mindset this weekend. Now go microwave something my friend – I look forward to the breath taking photos of it.
I HAVE BEEN LOOKING FOR THIS RECIPE FOREVER! You just changed my life. Yayyyy!
My boyfriend would go nuts for this for his birthday in a couple weeks. I think I’ll add some peanut butter and reese’s pieces to it. he’s a PB fanatic!
I love you/am super upset with you for this recipe! I love how easy you make it to have a freshly baked cookie, but I hate how I will want to make this every night for dessert!
These little cakes look amazing!
Mmm I neeed to try this!
I’ve tried this recipie like ten times and I have witnessed a miracle every time! These cookies are super yummy and a perfect late night snack. They are so easy to make and so fast to whip up that I had the recipie memorized after making it only 3 times! Thanks so much Christi! I now have a new treat that I make for my sugar crazed family every night! Thanks again!
Um, I’m doing this TONIGHT!
Oh and btw, I used to live in Nothern California and my friends and I would drive 30-45 minutes to the closest BJ’s JUST to order a pizookie! =]
These look amazing! I don’t have a microwave, any cooking tips on how long and what temp to bake them in the oven?? thanks!
Kristi, I usually bake mine on 325-350 (my oven runs hot so I do 325) for about 10-15 minutes. They are best if they are a bit underdone in the middle. And they are best in the oven – the microwave is great and quick, but the oven will give you that crust on the edges – SO good!
This was almost TOO easy to make. Evil – deliciously evil!
That is adorable and yummy!
I just made this a few minutes ago, and I loved it! It was delicious! In my opinion, it tasted better than store-bought cookie dough(:
Made these last night! Fantastic! I’ll never diet again
I was originally going to use another recipe, but did not have eggs. So glad I made this one!! Definitely going to try the brownie one next.
oh wow, genius! this looks as easy as pie, well easier than pie, by a mile easier than pie! Thank you for sharing, I know someone who will LOVE these! xxxx
Awesome! Just wondering, are these meant to have a fudgy toll house cookie texture or a cakey one? Thanks! This is great (:
Question-does this come out cakey or toll house cookie-like? Thanks!
I don’t think it’s cakey, more on the dense side, but I think that cakey is kind of a subjective term – but much more brownie like than cake like!
i love this . Thank u
I’m enjoying one of these right now – it is BEYOND delicious!!
I just made this although I was missing vanilla extract, salt, and chocolate chips. I mixed it up and popped it in the microwave for 50 seconds. When I took it out I drizzled CARAMEL on top, and it was yummy! Very satisfying
It’s like eating warm cookie dough, but without the worry of consuming raw eggs!
Can i make this in the oven?
Alysha, here is a non-homemade version that I do in the oven… http://www.lovefromtheoven.com/2012/11/29/cookie-a-la-mode-our-holiday-traditionsand-a-smuckers-top-your-holiday-giveaway/ Same basic idea/baking time.
this is so good, your amazing! thanks for the great idea!
HI! Thank you so much for posting this. My husband is a diabetic with a sweet tooth so this is the perfect way to control portions! I will also be using these for birthday dinners at home with a little ice cream for my two little boys. Cheers!
just made this and it’s so delicious! will be making many more times!!
I’ve made this like 20 times because its amazing, HOWEVER, I always used Country crock (margarine?)… I recently started buying unsalted butter instead, and tried to make this twice tonight with that being the only different thing and it didn’t turn out well at all. Odd!
I now keep a huge stock of the not yet microwaved batches in my fridge so I can microwave it whenever I’m craving a midnight snack. It’s AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!
Cannot wait to try this! It made me excited to read about the pizza cookie from Oregano’s as well, because I used to live across the street from Oregano’s as an ASU student, and now I miss it since I’ve moved to SC. Thanks!
Note to self: this cannot be made in advance- we will be trying again, and cooking right away. I was just trying to save some time!
Beth – no this is absolutely a heat and serve immediately type of dish.
Loved this. Substituted unsweetened applesauce for butter and used trivia for white sugar and used whole wheat flour and felt better about nutrition but either way portion control is where it’s at. The whole wheat version was delicious. Put fat free whip cream on top and was in heaven. Thanks for the post.
Just as a note, I did ended up doing it for about ~20 minutes at 350F in the toaster oven plus a five minute rest once out to get it to the right texture. This was probably a function of my choice of dish and that I used a toaster oven (not as heat efficient as a normal oven). Also, it was a bit crumbly, so if I would make this again I would use some sort of binder (part of a beaten egg, meringue powder, flax meal, etc.) to make it more gooey.
However, flavor was AMAZING and by far the best “single serving” baked good I’ve made yet.
I just made this, but maybe I did something wrong. When I mixed in the flour it was very dry, so I added some water. I cooked it, but it was very fluffy and a lot like a cake. Better luck next time
What a luscious and fabulous idea.
This is great when you don’t want a big batch of cookies hanging
around the house whispering your name.