Levain Bakery Inspired Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie Recipe

After making the amazingly delicious double dark chocolate Levain Bakery copycat recipe, I’ve been wanting to make the chocolate chip walnut cookie recipe.   After searching around the web, I decided to work with the copy cat Levain Bakery recipe from Parsley, Sage, Desserts & Line Drives and tweak it a bit.

I’ve never been to the Levain Bakery, never had one of their cookies and am not so sure I ever will, and really haven’t a clue if this actually tastes like their cookie, but this much I know…. This is one damn good cookie.

It maintains that slightly dough like consistency inside, which is heavenly.    After making this cookie, I don’t plan to be making the recipe off of the Nestle chocolate chip bag (though I will give it credit, it served me well for many years).

The biggest difference in this recipe for me was that it did not call for vanilla, and it included cornstarch.   At first this seemed really odd, but I remember my mom always adding a box of vanilla pudding mix to her chocolate chips cookies.   Given that the second ingredient on the pudding box is “modified food starch” (which apparently often means cornstarch), I figured it was a safe add in to try.

Here’s what you need…

Levain Bakery Walnut Chocolate Chip Copycat Cookie Recipe

2 sticks butter – cold and cut into cubes

1/2 cup granulated sugar

3/4 cups light brown sugar

3/4 cups dark brown sugar

2 eggs

3 cups flour (you may need slightly less or more)

1 & 1/2  tsp salt (I prefer sea salt)

2 tsp cornstartch

1 & 1/4 tsp baking powder

1/4 tsp baking soda

2 cups chocolate chips – I used one cup regular semi-sweet chips and one cup mini chips

Optional – 1/2 block of semi-sweet or dark chocolate (not unsweetened baker’s chocolate)

Optional – 1 cup walnuts or pecans

Directions

1.  Preheat oven to 375 degrees F

2.  In a large bowl/mixer bowl, cream together cubed butter and sugars until well blended and fluffy.

3.  Add eggs, one at a time, until well mixed.

4.  Add flour, salt, cornstartch, baking powder, baking soda & salt to butter, sugar and egg mixture until just combined.   This should be a very thick mixture, and not sticky.  If your dough is still sticky, try adding more flour, 1/8-1/4 cup at a time.

5.  Add in chocolate chips and nuts.   If you are using a block of chocolate, you will want to grate it and add it in as well.

You can even use a chocolate candy bar for this part.   The grated chocolate just adds a hint more chocolate in every bite.

Yay for chocolate, chocolate and more chocolate!

6.  Combine the dough and chocolate chips.   My dough was so thick that I had to do this by hand, a bit like kneading bread.

7.  Divide into portions to bake.   I scaled back a bit from the giant Levain Bakery size cookie and instead of making 12 cookies with this recipe, I made about 18.    I worked the dough into balls, and put them on the cookie sheet, leaving ample room between them.  I did not flatten the dough out at all.   I also did not use a silpat, parchment paper or grease the cookie sheets.   I’m a baking rebel when it comes to putting my cookies on the cookie sheets.

8.  Put into the oven to bake.    For my 18 cookies, each sheet took approximately 10 minutes.   Larger cookies will obviously take a few more minutes.  Watch them closely and don’t over bake, or you will ruin the gooey wonderfulness inside.   I pulled mine out as soon as I saw them start to lightly brown.

9.   Let cool and remove from pan.

10.  Break one open and eat.  Squeal with joy after tasting.   Figure out who to give them to or where to hide them so that you don’t eat the entire batch in one sitting.

Some day I am really going to have to try an actual Levain Bakery cookie.   So far the two knock offs have been AMAZING.    Next time I may have to try the dark chocolate peanut butter cookie.  Or the oatmeal, subbing out the raisins for butterscotch chips.    Either way, I have a feeling it will be scrumptious!

Enjoy!

Levain Bakery Copycat Cookies.  Seriously one of the best chocolate chip cookies I've ever made.

Share!

Comments

  1. says

    Okay – so I just think I’m going to blindly buzz everything you post! I’m in love with your creations! Great job!!! I saw your Oreo bronies on Baking is Hot the other day! Awesome job! Congrats!! ♥- Katrina

  2. Cassie says

    I love the way your cookies look! You NEED, and I mean NEED, to go to Levains! I had one of the cookies there a couple months ago, and right after I tasted it, I knew it would (from then on) be the last food I would want to eat if I knew I was going to kick it tomorrow. THEY ARE AMAZING.

  3. says

    First off, I just love your website. It makes me giggly like a kid in a candy store. So bright and delicious. Secondly, these look amazing. I’d stuff a little reese’s in there and call it a day! Perfect cookie!

  4. says

    Your cookie photos are beautiful. I only recently learned about the trick of adding pudding mix to your cookie dough and used chocolate pudding to make chocolate cherry chip cookies. They aren’t quite as puffy as yours though. I’ll have to try the cornstarch trick sometime. Thanks for sharing!

    Here’s what my chocolate pudding cherry chip cookies looked like: http://bit.ly/gZ4HVg .

  5. Annabelle says

    Second recipe I’ve tried of yours…again…amazing! Great recipe. Baked up exactly as pictured! Amazing nutty/buttery aroma while baking. The salt in this cookie pulls out the flavor of both the cookie and the chocolate unlike other recipes, including my previous go-to Martha Stewart choc. chip cookie. Thanks for sharing!!

    • says

      Annabelle – so glad the recipes are working for you. Isn’t it the best chocolate chip cookie??? I truly don’t know that I’ll use any of my old recipes. This one is just perfect. LOVE it!

  6. Liz says

    These are phenomenal. Made them for the second time today. So so close to the real thing. Really the only thing different is that I didn’t use the quality chocolate as Levain. Yummy. I want the eat them all.

  7. Lindsey says

    Just made these tonight. I have been searching for months for the “perfect” chocolate chip cookies…chewy and thick, and these are it!! I love them! Gooey, thick, sweet. Thank you!

  8. Amber says

    I just made some chocolate chip cookies last night from the recipe on the back of the Gold flour bag. But then I started thinking (DREAMING) about the Levain Bakery cookies and how PERFECT they were. I used to live on the exact same street, same block! as this bakery in NYC. And hardly a day went by that I wouldnt stop on in for these molten-shelled ooey-gooey-on-the-inside nuggets of heaven! I so often find myself craving a Levain chocolate chip cookie. And while my cookies turn out similar fresh out of the oven (only flat), I simply MUST try this recipe! Hopefully it will bring back those heavenly memories =)

  9. Emma says

    I just went to Levain’s for the first time about a week ago so I’m soooo excited to try this recipe because their cookies were wonderful and these look amazing!

  10. Carly says

    Awesome!! WOW…My daughter just came and grabbed one and said “Mom I have always wanted a cookie that was not flat”.

  11. Rae says

    I recently made these cookies for Boss’ Day and let me tell you that they came out better than expected! I too owned a whoopie pan, both the heart and circle shape, and I didn’t realize that I put too much dough in the pan until it was too late. Needless to say I had massive sized chocolate cookies and no one seemed to mind when I put them on the table to eat. Thanks for the inspiration. Now, I’ll make the double chocolate chip Levain cookie!

  12. eileen says

    I went to Levain yesterday to check out the cookie. I live in NYC and have passed the bakery a thousand times, but for some reason never went in. Maybe 15 years ago I went in, but do not remember what I ordered. The cookie was good. Largish…pricy at $4. But not the amazing cookie that I have been reading about. They don’t serve it warm, and I think that would make it better. I wanted to taste test it against the NYT Jocques Torres cc cookie that King Arthur recipes tweaked. I have been making that KA cookie of late and we really like it. I am going to do a batch of yours and a batch of those and then do a taste comparison. I liked that Levain cookie was chunky, not flat. Have you tried making the NYT cookie or the King Arthur variation? It is excellent but it is not the cookie batter center type cookie. Maybe there is room for both in my house (and stomach).

  13. Peter P. says

    Cookies look amazing! I was planning on making this myself and was wondering how many minutes you pre-heat the oven?

  14. says

    I finally found the best chocolate chip cookie!
    I am so exciting that I can make those awesome cookie!
    but,
    my country’s measurement system is different from yours.
    how weigh 1 sticks of butter? 113g is OK??

  15. John says

    Awesome recipe…I saw the pic and thought that’s what I’m talking about…no flat cookie. I hate flat cookies… I did however sub in 2.5 cups of oats for 1 cup of flour….kind of an experiment, but wow it worked!!! I love me some chocolate chip oatmeal cookies and couldn’t resist! Used a silpat and they came out with a nice solid bottom and soft gooey insides. 11 min at 375. I think next I’ll make the recipe as written above and compare to this oatmeal version.

  16. Steve says

    I saw this receipe and wanted to give it a try. I made a batch for my wife for Valentines day. WOW, these are GREAT.

    The only change that I made was the I made 16 cookies, not 18 and left them in for 13 minutes. The only downside is that each cookie has approximatly 380 caloires. Unlike Lays, you should only eat one.

    I can’t wait to try the other receipes.

    • says

      Mara, honestly I never really pay much attention to salt or unsalted butter, and flip flop between the two interchangeably. That said, I like a saltier taste to cut sweetness, so most often I buy and use salted butter. I’m really flexible in my ingredients in things, which is one of my challenges as a baking blogger, I’m not always scientific – trying to improve that!

  17. says

    I’m making these tomorrow. My friend was raving about Levain’s cookies, but she’s much closer to the bakery than I am (I’m in Kansas for goodness’ sake!). So I found your recipe on the webs! I am sad I am lacking a few ingredients because I’d really like to make them *right now*.

    I, too, almost always use salted butter when I bake, even if the recipe calls for unsalted. Nothing has ever bombed, and after having tasted cookies without salted butter, I have decided that my way is better (good thing, because I’m not changin’ my way).

    Love your site!

  18. Becca says

    These looks amazing!! Can’t wait to try them.

    PS, did John really replace one cup of flour w two and a half cups of oats? Sounds like a typo, but thought I’d ask…

  19. KathyS says

    Seriously delicious. Taste is wonderful and texture is PERFECT. I thought they might be too sweet – but not so. Top of my Cookie List! Thanks.

  20. Elly says

    I’m trying the recipe. But very hard to find the stick butter.
    If I use normal butter, how many grams to use

  21. Samantha says

    This recipe is the best! I only had King Arthur white whole wheat flour in the house and the texture was still amazing. Thick, tender, and chewy with a crispy exterior. Tempted to just add vanilla extract when I make next time. :)))))))

  22. says

    Wow, these were such a hit! I received the most incredible feedback! I have tried Levain’s original version and these come pretty darn close :)

  23. Maia says

    I don’t know why this seems to be working out perfectly for you guys but mine turned out a lot darker compared to the picture, and they were too salty (I mean, really). Plus, I noticed that your dough looked kind of dry whereas mine was oily to the point that after the cookies were sitting on the tray (while I was waiting for the oven) I noticed that there were small puddles of oil under them.

    I might try this again just to make a few changes and see if I can find out what I did wrong :/

    • says

      Maia, yes, my dough was very dry. I usually aim for a dry dough an will often add more flour if I feel that it’s too sticky. Hmm was your butter cold? This is one of the only cookie recipes I have that calls specifically for COLD butter. The color thing has me a bit stumped. Did you use the mix of white sugar, light sugar and dark brown sugar? Did you go with 1.5 teaspoons of salt? That can always be omitted if you prefer, for my taste I like a salt to balance the sweet – but really the only thing salt does is change the flavor, so you don’t have to use it.

  24. rose-marie says

    Its Good Friday and Im thinking, have to make some cakes or yummy things for Easter Sunday, after we have the big lunch…dessert etc. so choch walnut cookies it is…
    I live in Australia so have never been to Levain bakery. Your cookies sound heavenly…so wish me luck with the cooking.. and happy easter everyone..

  25. Melanie says

    This look WONDERFULLY DELICIOUS!!! I wonder – is there a way to alter the recipe a bit to add oatmeal? Oatmeal chocolate chip is our family’s favorite, but I’d like to try this recipe if I could have some help with the oatmeal thing…

    • says

      Melanie, I agree, oatmeal choc chip is the BEST. I would cut back a bit on the flour and add in the oatmeal. Maybe not a exact swap, maybe take out 1/2 cup flour and add 3/4 cup oatmeal type. I will put that on my list of things to try and share on here – LOVE oatmeal in cookies!

  26. Marne says

    I recently moved from New York. I am missing it today. This was just the little pick me up that I needed!! Thanks

    • says

      Anna, I have one that is, most are not. Honestly I think I picked it up at Target probably 8+ years ago. My favorite baking sheets are the plain regular ones, and I love the non-stick ones that Crate & Barrel sells.

  27. says

    I, too, have just made and posted a knock-off for Levain Bakery’s signature chocolate chip cookie. Only the recipe I tried had some cake flour in it. The cake flour along with all-purpose flour is supposed to be the formula for pastry flour. It’s said that pastry flour is the secret ingredient in Levain’s cookie. All I can say is that these cookies are absolutely AMAZING! Enjoyed browsing your blog…when you have a chance, stop by and visit mine! http://www.fransfavs.com/2012/07/levain-bakery-chocolate-chip-walnut-cookie-clone/

  28. Elizabeth says

    Just made these, I didn’t have dark brown sugar, so I just substituted light brown sugar. The cookies still came out great! The first batch I rolled them like she did, but found that they didn’t spread at all. So, the next batch I rolled them and then flattened them out a bit. Despite not spreading the first batch tasted wonderful. And the second batch was perfecto!

  29. Susan says

    These were amazing! I have never been to Levain Bakery as do not live near NYC, but I have made my fair share (and MORE) of chocolate chip cookie recipes and I have potentially found my new favorite! I’m a lover of Alton Brown’s Chewy and think I could love both as they both offer wonderful characteristics depending on what you’re looking for. Due to the large quanties of flour, I think the Levain can dry out more quickly, than the Chewy. However, if consuming or presenting for consumption right the day of than Levain may have one up on the Chewy. Gasp…did I just say that?! However, the Chewy could offer up a richer taste a few days after and it may be due to the higher butter:flour ratio. Hmmm…I did bake the Levain cookie with and without toasted pecans.Both equally delicious, but since I LOVE nuts with chocolate the pecan version wins hands down too. I think I will have a bake-off of the Levain and Chewy just to be sure of my allegiance and plan on making other Levain copycats as the Fall is upon us. Did anyone suggest butterscotch and oatmeal? :)

    • says

      John, there has been much conversation about cornstarch being one of Levain’s “secret” ingredients, so just trying to replicate their delicious cookies!

  30. Maria Jose says

    The best cookie recipe I’ve ever tried. Incredibly yummy. Everything is perfect. Wonderfully delicious. A piece of heaven in your mouth.Thank you for sharing this recipe.
    xxx from Spain

Trackbacks

  1. […] Levain Bakery Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie Recipe – A Copycat Version Related Posts:Easy Recipe For No Bake Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Truffles For cookie dough and chocolate lovers alike, combine the two in a decadent truffle. It's an easy recipe and cheap to make. Surprise them tonight. Read …chocolate chip cookie recipe | Snack Girl Snack Girl has a secret. With over 27 inches of snow outside her window, she can't look a vegetable in the eye…. View post: chocolate …Young & Free Mississippi – Blog – Recipe: Chocolate Chip Bacon Cookies Any good southern girl knows that when guests come into town one should always have baked goods prepared! So… I made cookies! Chocolate chip BACON …The easiest & most delicious cookie recipe. | RhodeyGirl Tests Before I know it, I'm going to be able to actually call myself a baker! Ever since conquering my fear of baking with my first …Chinese New Year Cookies: Walnut Biscuit (Hup Toh Soh) Lovely crunchy and fragrant walnut biscuit that is loved by the young and old. Read the rest here: Chinese New Year Cookies: Walnut Biscuit (Hup Toh … Categories: Al, Bake, chocolate, Cola, cook, cookies, de, for, it, make, nut, or, Recipe, Recipes, The Tags: all-make, bakery, chewy-chocolate, copy-cat, levain, levain-bakery, makes-amazing, walnut-cookie […]

  2. […] I did find this recipe however, and gave it a whirl, the key here is pretty much making the cookies as big as your hand-That’s all.  Claire and her boyfriend, Adam, approved! Happy Days had by all Bake some cookies with your siblings or some sibling-like person over the holidays ok? Really, they are one of the best baking buddies/food critics.  Noted for their brutal honesty and frank evaluation!  If it’s good it’s reallly good. […]

  3. […] absolutely obsessed with cookies lately.  Specially chocolate chip.  With nuts.  I tried to make these the other day and they did not turn out like hers at all.  I’m going to go ahead an blame […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>